Sunday, May 10, 2026

The New P0rnogr@phers Are 26 Years 0ld

I still remember the excitement of hearing "Mass Romantic" on college radio for the first time.  The New Pornographers sounded so different to my ears from other indie rock of 2000. It was a maximalist form of pop music, jam-packed with novel lyrical and melodic ideas, plus vocal arrangements that recalled groups like The Turtles. If you need a reminder of what was popular that year, check out Allmusic Loves 2000 or the Fluxblog 2000 Survey mix.

To be fair, I hadn't heard Zumpano (Carl Newman's former band), and it was a few years before I bought King James Version (Harvey Danger's remarkable 2000 album, which also featured elaborate vocal harmonies and clever lyrics).  Who but The New Pornographers could rhyme "set the scene" with "Byzantine" -- or create an irresistable chorus from the phrase, "Nobody knows the wreck of the soul the way you do"?

The liner notes to their debut announced, "We are The New Pornographers. This album is the second creation of The Blue Curtain," begging the question of what The Blue Curtain was, and what its first creation might have been.  I suspect it was Blaine Thurier's film The Low Self-Esteem Girl (which featured his bandmates Carl Newman and Dan Bejar as actors).

Dan Bejar had released Destroyer's Thief album in 1999, and Neko Case released Furnace Room Lullaby in 2000, adding to the impression that The New Pornographers was an indie supergroup, or a collective.  Dan's contributions to New Pornographers' albums gradually diminished as Destroyer flourished, and he left after 2014's Brill Bruisers.  

Neko Case has also had a successful solo career, and she collaborates with many other artists.  I'm pleased to report that Neko is still a New Pornographer and can be heard on the new album The Former Site Of.  She harmonizes beautifully with Carl Newman, but she is lead vocalist less often than she was back in the early 2000's (on songs like "Letter From An Occupant", "All For Swinging You Around" and "Mass Romantic").

John Collins was a founding New Pornographer, and he balances his work with Destroyer and other projects. Todd Fancey joined as lead guitarist in 2003, and he maintains a solo career as well as his membership as a Pornographer in good stead.  The same is true of Kathryn Calder, who joined in 2005 and also leads the group FrontpersonWikipedia has a helpful chart of the New Pornographers' membership over the years.  Ironically, a drummer was recently fired after an arrest for child pornography.

Here's a CD-length "best of" The New Pornographers, starting with a song from the new album and working backwards to 2000.  The New Pornographers are touring North America through October 2026.  A word of advice, if you're going: I've seen Neko have audience members thrown out for recording cell phone videos.  

Buy The Former Site Of 

Buy tickets to see The New Pornographers

Elsewhere On The Blog: Neko Case's sister from another mister, Kelly Hogan


10 comments:

  1. LINK: https://pixeldrain.com/u/ifFnHxzA

    So many great songs got cut to keep this under 80 minutes. If you want to hear more, I recommend "Twin Cinema" and "Together" as good albums to start with. Enjoy!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. TOGETHER is my favorite album by them!

      Another great comp, Jon!

      Delete
    2. Listening now to Votive, very impressive, thanks Jon!

      Delete
  2. I have seen them live a bunch of times, including at Maxwell's in Hoboken (Twin Cinemas tour), when they weren't as big as they became later, and at the Matador at 21 record label anniversary festival, in Las Vegas, of all places.

    I was an early adopter, because "Letter from an Occupant" picked up a lot of airplay on WFMU (New Jersey's great freeform station) in 2000. The band played a session for the station in 2010 and included a great cover of Fleetwood Mac's "I Walk a Thin Line" in their set; you can hear that one on WFMU's online archives.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, James! There's a WFMU comp CD where they do a Sparks cover (Throw Her Away And Get A New One). And I think Tom Scharpling directed one of their music videos?

      The New Pornographers version of "Think About Me" on the Fleetwood Mac tribute (Just Tell Me That You Want Me) was outstanding, and I love their Rock*A*Teens cover (Don't Destroy This Night). Merge Records seems like a good label for them.

      Really one of the best rock bands of this century, if you ask me. These songs are good mood food.

      Delete
  3. I just saw them in PA and their older songs still soar…and I know this is going to be unpopular statement, but both The Pornographers and Teenage Fanclub’s (another unheralded brilliant pop band!) later material is very slow, ponderous and dare I say boring. I get it, you’re older and want to take a stab and more thoughtful lyrics…but where are the soaring harmonies that made me love you….? It seems like Merge records is also a place where old beloved bands go to die a slow melancholic death.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ouch! You could also say that about Yep Roc Records.... I won't disagree with you that the more recent records have fewer thrills, and "the soaring harmonies that made me love you" are what I was listening for when choosing tracks for this comp. When I hear "Darling Shade" and "High Ticket Attractions", I'm thinking "THAT'S the stuff!" Those songs could fit on Twin Cinema. But maybe for Carl Newman, writing that type of song feels like treading water.

      Despite being slow and ponderous, "You Won't Need Those Where You're Going" is really lovely and touching. At least to these old ears.

      Thanks for the comment, Benz Oyl! How's your aunt Olive these days -- still feisty?

      Delete
    2. Here's some interesting trivia: Olive Oyl's last name was Peroxide.

      Delete